Trademark survey, intellectual property, trademark infringement

Is A Trademark Infringement Survey Really Necessary?

    posted on          2021-11-25 06:19:39, USA

Posted by: Rhonda Harper MBA

Is A Trademark Infringement Survey Really Necessary? Yes, according to the John Marshall Review of Intellectual Property Law. "Courts have continually utilized surveys to show evidence of secondary meaning, generieness, dilution, and functionality in trademark litigation." - The John Marshall Review of Intellectual Property Law, Robert Thornberg

Trademark Infringement Survey
Survey evidence is often used in trademark litigation to test the likelihood of confusion and trademark dilution because a survey gauges the "subjective mental associations and reactions of prospective purchasers."' Since trademark holders are often unable to provide evidence of actual confusion when proving likelihood of confusion, courts often look toward surveys as strong circumstantial evidence.

Litigants use survey evidence to convince a court that consumer confusion exists (or does not exist) between two marks. Courts hold consumer surveys in high esteem. Surveys are considered to have both widespread acceptance and vital influence in trademark infringement. In fact, courts have even faulted litigants for not conducting a survey even when the litigant suggests it was cost prohibitive.

Critical to the success of a survey is the adherence to standard methods and protocols. Case outcomes can turn on survey evidence. One of the most notable cases, "Black and Decker v. Positec," illustrates this point. On appeal, the court overturned a $54 million verdict in the Plaintiff's favor solely because the survey conducted unreliable and the expert who conducted it prejudicial.

Ms. Rhonda Harper, MBA
Retained by more than 130 law firms, Ms. Rhonda Harper is courtroom proven in virtually every circuit along with JAMS and TTAB. Ms. Harper's 30 year career includes serving as a Fortune 100 chief marketing officer and an adjunct marketing professor. In addition to providing litigation consulting and research in the areas of business, licensing, marketing, advertising, and strategy, Ms. Harper is routinely retained to formulate expert surveys, conduct rebuttal critiques, or construct rebuttal surveys to show the potential difference in results with properly designed and executed surveys. She has extensive experience and a deep understanding of survey design, sampling, question construction, data analysis, and the methodological pitfalls that can introduce bias or systematic error.